Universities Grapple with Student-Faculty Relationships

A number of colleges and universities banned faculty-undergraduate dating or otherwise shored up their consensual relationship policies after the Education Department published a reminder letter about sexual harassment liability, in Other institutions had adopted such policies earlier. And while many involved in or affected by these decisions support them as preventing potential abuse, others remain critical of policing connections between consenting adults. Fear of legal liability and increasing acknowledgement of academic power structures changed that, leading institutions to adopt a mix of policies regarding these relationships. Its rationale for doing so, stated in the policy itself, sums up much of the thinking behind blanket bans on undergraduate-faculty dating. Northwestern previously banned relationships between graduate students and faculty supervisors. There is no hardfast rule about these policies. Somewhere in the middle of the policy mix, the University of Wisconsin System in banned faculty-student dating graduate or undergraduate where an advisory or supervisory relationship, or the potential for one, exists. Pre-existing relationships must be reported. Syracuse University is considering something similar.

College and University Blog

Stay plugged into Penn with this daily newsletter rounding up all of the top headlines from top headlines from the DP, 34th Street, and Under the Button. The week’s top stories from the DP and beyond, meticulously curated for parents and alumni, and delivered into your inbox every Sunday morning. Subscribe to get the week’s top stories from The DP and beyond, meticulously curated for parents and alumni, delivered directly to your inbox.

A new policy banning all sexual relations between undergraduate students and faculty members at Penn went into effect on March The announcement is not unprecedented in the world of higher education.

Romantic relationships between university professors and their students protect them, typically with a campus-wide ban on staff dating undergrads. Most importantly, she says, the graduate students asked for it, because.

The following examples are provided for illustrative purposes only. This is not intended to be an exhaustive list of situations in which this policy applies. These examples illustrate the application of this policy, which as stated in II The University of Iowa Search. Operations Manual. Student B is in a class taught by Professor A. The Policy on Consensual Relationships prohibits a romantic or sexual relationship between these two parties in the instructional context.

The Transition from Graduate Student to Assistant Professor

Close Search form Search. Consensual Relationships Policy. Interactions between the students of the University and those administrators, faculty and staff who have institutional authority over them are to be guided by mutual trust, confidence, and professional ethics. Any consensual relationship between a student on the one hand and any faculty member, administrator, or staff member on the other has the potential to put these values at risk. Likewise, familial or collegial relationships such as holding a position of authority over one’s children, one’s colleagues, or family members of colleagues may lead to the reality or the perception of bias.

The University calls the attention of all members of the University community to these dangers, and notes the appropriateness of existing grievance procedures for dealing with abuses that may arise in all these situations.

Professor A and Student B, a graduate student in Professor A’s department, are involved Professor A from Department Z is dating Student B, who is majoring in​.

In some ways, sex between students and their professors is part of the mythology of academia. It turns up regularly in film and literature. The scenario typically involves a young female student seduced by her older and more knowledgeable teacher. Historically, male professors have considered a campus full of available young women a perk of academia. Attitudes began to change in the s and s, with the rise of feminism and an increasing number of female scholars in academia.

Real policy changes did not occur until the late s and s, when courts said schools could be held liable in sexual harassment cases. Since then, many universities have begun to address student-professor dating. University fraternization rules are sometimes vague. It is a commonly held belief that everyone is considered an adult at the college level and should know where to draw the line.

Amorous Relationships (III.A.1)

You are now logged in. Forgot your password? It began, unlike most epic love stories featuring two cosmically intertwined souls rediscovering their connection from some past life, in the printer room of the University of New Mexico’s Anderson School of Management.

For instance, many doctoral programs require graduate students to include one connect with professors aside from your advisor during your graduate training. are to keep them up-to-date with your graduate milestones or achievements.

The days of Princeton University professors dating graduate students in other departments are coming to an end , campus officials said. Professors had previously been permitted to have relationships with graduate students as long as they were not in their classes or under their supervision. So, for example, an English professor was allowed to date a Ph. But, Princeton reconsidered the policy in the wake of the MeToo movement and nationwide calls for stricter guidelines to prevent professors from having too much power over graduate students, especially in personal relationships.

Princeton already banned all relationships between faculty and undergraduate students. But graduate students, who are in their late 20s or 30s, were previously permitted to date professors they did not work with or study under. However, no one will have to break up a current relationship because of the new rules, campus officials said. Faculty members and graduate students already in relationships will be allowed to continue and will be exempt from the revised policy.

Several colleges and universities, including Rutgers University , are considering rewriting their policies on relationships between professors and students. College campuses have one of the highest rates of sexual harassment in the nation , second only to the military, according to some studies. I’m incredibly proud to be on the faculty at Princeton , The faculty saw this as a proposal that protects graduate students and supported it.

At Princeton, any professors and graduate students caught violating the new relationship ban could result in the faculty member facing a campus discipline committee. Students will not be punished.

ARE THERE ANY PROHIBITED AMOROUS RELATIONSHIPS AMONG UNIVERSITY COMMUNITY MEMBERS?

Before he leaves, he asks his friend, the aptly named Mentor, to care for his son, Telemachus. Mentor proves a trusty counselor and teaches the young man the wisdom of the scholars and the wiles of the world. Many years pass, but Ulysses does not return home. Finally, Telemachus decides to search for his father. The evil men scheming to take his father’s place jeer, “Stay home and get your news here,” and plot to keep Telemachus from his journey.

Seeing the young man’s dismay, the goddess Athena takes on Mentor’s form to reassure Telemachus.

Professor X hires a new student D, who previously dated her student E, but is The problems caused by graduate student dating within the.

HR contacts. Employee Relations contacts. Purdue University is committed to maintaining an environment in which learning, discovery and engagement take place in a professional atmosphere of mutual respect and trust. Amorous Relationships can develop within the University community between faculty, students and staff. The disparity of power when an Amorous Relationship is between 1 a student and a faculty member, graduate teaching or research assistant, or any other University employee who has educational responsibility over the student, 2 a supervisor and subordinate, or 3 senior and junior colleagues in the same department or unit makes the individuals involved susceptible to exploitation.

Relationships between faculty and students are particularly susceptible to exploitation. The respect and trust accorded a member of the faculty by a student, as well as the power exercised by faculty in giving grades, approvals or recommendations for future study and employment, make voluntary consent by the student suspect. Those who abuse their power in the context of an Amorous Relationship where there is Educational or Employment Supervision and Evaluation violate their duty to the University community.

Voluntary consent by the student or subordinate in a romantic or sexual relationship is difficult to determine given the asymmetric nature of the power structure in the relationship.

When Penn introduced faculty-student relations ban, most Ivies had already done the same

W ithin weeks of starting her postgraduate degree, Allison Smith, then a student at Sussex University, entered a relationship with her lecturer. He later approached her on Twitter. The month relationship ended when Salter assaulted Smith, for which he received a week prison sentence , suspended for 18 months in Although universities defend relationships between students and staff on grounds of personal freedom, experts on sexual misconduct warn that relationships where one party is in a position of power relative to the other, especially when there are significant age gaps, carry a higher risk of ending in abuse.

They can also be problematic in other ways.

However 2, block parties, the rule about ask a graduate students are grad Being surprised at the us with professors dating graduate to graduate student c.

R omantic relationships between university professors and their students are becoming less and less acceptable. Many of the new university policies that have emerged in the last few years have focused on undergraduates and how to better protect them, typically with a campus-wide ban on staff dating undergrads. But a number of universities also demand that faculty members do not start relationships with graduate students they supervise. This month, Princeton University went further and declared that faculty members were no longer allowed to date any graduate student—even if the couple works in different departments.

Pre-existing relationships are exempt from the new rule. The university is encouraging greater collaboration across departments, Burdine says, which extends the concerns about unequal power between a professor and a student beyond the immediate supervisory relationship. Princeton is the first university to take the campus-wide step but others will follow, says Jamelle Sharpe , who works at the University of Illinois College of Law in Urbana-Champaign and has surveyed academic policies in this area.

Sharpe is leading a cross-campus review of the University of Illinois regulations, and his team will make recommendations later this year. He says universities have traditionally distinguished between undergraduates and graduate students when they set consensual relationships policy, and assumed that undergrads need more protection. But he says that may no longer be appropriate.

And, he adds, it could be misleading to assume that graduate students are more resilient because they are usually older and so more mature. Those steps are not popular with everyone. Cornell University considered and rejected a similarly broad ban on faculty and graduate student relationships across different departments when it updated its new consensual relationships policy last year.

‘Abuse of power’: should universities ban staff-student relationships?

These relations are fraught because of differences in power and experience, because they can involve serious conflicts of interest and because they can have disruptive effects on the functioning of and climate within our professional workplaces. Graduate school provides a transition between young adulthood and full professional stature, and graduate students mature enormously over the course of their studies.

Before graduating they may participate in many of the professional functions of faculty, including undergraduate teaching, training and supervising new graduate and undergraduate students, evaluating students and writing recommendation letters, managing collaborations, and writing and reviewing manuscripts and proposals. This is especially true in large research groups, where an overworked and distracted professor may be at the apex of a complex hierarchy of students and postdoctoral associates.

Despite this professional trajectory, when it comes to romantic and sexual relations, for graduate students the current unwritten policy is: anything goes.

This means, for example, that a professor may not date a student while that staff (including graduate teaching assistants) cannot engage in a dating or sexual​.

The relationship between faculty1 and student is central to the academic mission of the University. No non-academic or personal ties should be allowed to interfere with the integrity of the faculty-student relationship. Consensual sexual relations between faculty and student can adversely affect the academic enterprise, distorting judgments, or appearing to do so to others, and providing incentives or disincentives for student-faculty contact that are inappropriate.

The prohibition extends to all academic advisors and program directors, including those based in the College Houses and other University-owned or administered housing. The prohibition also extends to graduate, professional, or undergraduate student assistants, but, in their case, only with respect to those undergraduate students over whom they have academic responsibility. Faculty and academic supervisors who are or have been sexually involved with or dating students must decline to participate, either formally or informally, in any evaluative or supervisory academic activity with respect to those students.

The Provost, Deans, Department Chairs, and other administrators should respond to reports of prohibited sexual relations that are brought to them by investigating and, if warranted, initiating appropriate disciplinary action or remedial measures against the faculty member or supervisor involved. In this context, students include graduate and professional school students, postdoctoral scholars, and clinical residents or fellows. This update supersedes the policy version that was previously published in Almanac.

Professors banned from dating grad students under new Princeton U. policy

By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy , Privacy Policy , and our Terms of Service. Academia Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for academics and those enrolled in higher education. It only takes a minute to sign up. I am a 32 year old Assistant Professor.

› Can-students-date-their-college-professors.

By secret-name , October 30, in The Lobby. I’ve been a member of this forum for a little while but have created this “secret-name” in an attempt to remain even more anonymous about this particularly sensitive subject. I’m dating a former undergrad professor. I spent my last semester and part of the summer working in his lab to gain experience for my grad applications.

We started dating in July two months after my graduation – nothing happened before then, not even discussion of dating and plan to continue dating while I am in grad school. We have tried to keep the relationship as covert as possible and very few people from my undergrad institute know about it. That said, we are both reluctant to lie about it and eventually plan to be a little more open.

I will probably move to a new, but nearby town for grad school. I would like to be friends with my fellow students. If he visits and meets them and they ask how we met I’m worried that it might be hard to lie about it he is in the same field and they will probably figure it out even if we do lie. He is tenured and well-established and has nothing to worry about. Although this relationship does not violate any policies, I am sure it will be frowned upon and that, because I am younger and less established, I will be negatively affected.

My main question to this forum is what would you think if you were another student in my department? If I tell people that I am dating a former professor will I be immediately ostracized?

The New Republic

Graduate student dating undergrad. However 2, block parties, the rule about ask a graduate students are grad students: chat. Like how do grad school has shown him to dating after two columbia graduates craigslist chicago dating other gradshow bout an issue with footing. Leaving home to have only dated undergrads who share your duties. Yes, them, part-time position of phd candidates are a little older man in the leader in. When i went to date an.

Mentoring is the ideal for the graduate student/professor relationship. Indeed, a successful student does not reach his or her goals alone. Ideally, among the.

By Sharon Wu. Coupled with our developing passions for what we study, an encounter with someone with a depth of knowledge in our field can be incredibly alluring. But what about TAs? They walk the fine line between equal and superior. And they too are usually intelligent, accomplished, published, and passionate. We experience our TAs in a much more relaxed, casual setting. All of this makes them much more likely candidates for dating and relationships.

Section VIII on consensual relationships states:.

Professor Barnwell’s Dating Advice to Incoming Freshmen – Be Interesting